February 12th, 2014

House of Fraser pigeon logo ruffles feathers

Clothing brands often use graphic logos on garments, such as on the left breast of shirt or jumper.  Some of these graphic logos are instantly recognisable as denoting a particular brand and registered as trade marks.  Well known examples include the Lacoste crocodile, the Original Penguin and the Ralph Lauren polo player.

Use of a graphic logo in this way was considered by the High Court recently in a trade mark infringement claim brought by Jack Wills against House of Fraser.

Since around 2007 Jack Wills has used three different variations of a logo depicting a pheasant in profile wearing a top hat and carrying a cane on carrier bags, swing tickets, promotional materials as well as on clothing (e.g. embroidered on the exterior of shirts, sweaters and ankle socks).  Jack Wills registered a version of the Mr Wills Logo as a trade mark in the UK and EU for goods including “clothing” in class 25 (the “Mr Wills Logo”).

Mr Wills

The Mr Wills Logo

 

 

 

 

 

In November 2011, House of Fraser started using a mark comprising the silhouette of a pigeon wearing a top hat and bow tie on its own ‘Linea’ range of men’s clothing, including embroidered on the exterior of shirts, t-shirts, sweaters and ankle socks (the “Pigeon Logo”).

Pigeon Logo

The Pigeon Logo

 

 

 

 

 

Jack Wills objected to the use of the Pigeon Logo by House of Fraser and issued a claim for trade mark infringement and passing off which was successful on the following grounds:

The High Court held that a significant proportion of average consumers (i.e. consumer of men’s clothing, in particular casual clothing), relying on their imperfect recollection, would mistake the Pigeon Logo for the Mr Wills Logo, or a variant of it, and be confused into believing that clothing bearing the logos, originated from the same or an economically linked source. Relevant to this finding was the fact that the Mr Wills Logo was distinctive and there was a high degree of conceptual similarity between the two logos which not only depict birds but specifically silhouettes of birds wearing the accessories of an English gentleman, notably top hats.

The High Court also held that House of Fraser’s use of the Pigeon Logo would, without due cause, take unfair advantage of the reputation of the Mr Wills Logo.  The High Court found that House of Fraser’s use of the Pigeon Logo on garments had “brand” significance and was not merely ornamentation.  By adopting an aspect of the get-up associated with Jack Wills, House of Fraser enhanced the attraction of its own Linea brand of goods and sought to influence the economic behaviour of consumers of those goods.  As a result, there would be a subtle transfer of image of the Mr Wills Logo to the Pigeon Logo, whether or not this was House of Fraser’s intention.

This case shows that use of a graphic logo on garments can have “branding” impact on consumers, even where the graphic logo is used in the context of an established brand.   Before using a graphic logo in this way, you should do some due diligence and may wish to obtain a clearance search to determine whether any third party has earlier rights in a similar sign.  You should think carefully about whether your proposed use is likely to cause confusion amongst consumers or take unfair advantage of the reputation of a third party’s trade mark or get-up.

Shirt birds

Shirts bearing each of the marks

Jumper birds

Jumpers bearing each of the marks

Leave a comment

As you may have heard, the internet is about to undergo a major expansion. The changes apply to generic top-level domains (“gTLDs”) – the letters immediately following the final dot in an Internet address. Fashionista read recently in the FT about London successfully applying for its own domain: .london, which will no doubt appeal to many […]

Leave a comment
August 14th, 2013

Zero support for zero hours?

Fashionista couldn’t help but notice the recent furore in both the press and parliament relating to business’ use of zero-hours contracts.  As reported in the Guardian, the most recent development being the legal action brought by an individual against Sports Direct, which has highlighted the company’s alleged ‘excessive’ use of such contracts.  With the use […]

Leave a comment

The pop star Rihanna has successfully made out her claim that Topshop’s sale of unauthorised t-shirts bearing her image amounted to “passing off”. In reaching his decision, Mr Justice Birss held that the elements for a passing-off claim had been satisfied.  These elements, known as the “classic trinity”, are: (i) goodwill, (ii) misrepresentation leading to confusion […]

1 Comment

It seems only just yesterday that Britain was celebrating the wedding of the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge, and with it, a huge boost to the retail sector. Now, just days from the arrival of their first child, the couple is again at the centre of the nation’s attention – and firmly in the minds of […]

Leave a comment
April 12th, 2013

Don’t mess with Wang!

Look what has caught Fashionista’s eye whilst travelling to Belgium – an article in the flemish newspaper De Standaard reporting on Vera Wang’s initiative to act against copying .   So upset is this ever so chic designer at the repeated efforts to copy her beautiful wedding resses that in her Shanghai bridal boutique clients  […]

Leave a comment

Fashionista has a serious shopping habit.  Will her disposable income be reduced  by this week’s budget?  So like all dedicated shoppers she will be tuning in to this week’s budget and not just to see the latest in red bags. To make life simple, on Wednesday 20 March she will be logging on to see […]

Leave a comment

As the advertisements in this Fashionista’s web browser certainly seem to know about her taste in shoes, Fashionista was interested to learn that on 4 February, a new set of online behavioural advertising (OBA) rules came into effect, aiming to secure transparency and control for web users. The new rules will be enforced by the […]

Leave a comment
January 30th, 2013

Harris Tweed defends its name

Fashionista is unlikely to be the only one to notice the rising popularity of all things home-made including Harris Tweed, the only fabric produced in commercial quantities by traditional hand weaving methods. Made from virgin wool it is dyed and then spun in the homes of the islanders of the Outer Hebrides. Last year saw […]

Leave a comment

Breaking news for the Belgian Fashion Industry ? The Belgian Supreme Court recently ruled that the sales ‘black-out period’ is contrary to European Law. In January 2010 Fashionista was fascinated to learn about Belgium’s outsider status in the EU as it comes to its regulation of sales (read here). To date Belgian fashion traders are […]

Leave a comment